Carey Law Firm, llc - DWI and Criminal Defense
RSS Follow Become a Fan

Delivered by FeedBurner


Categories

McNeely in Minnesota
Minnesota Crime Statistics
Minnesota DWI Blood Testing
Minnesota DWI Conviction and Entry into Canada
Minnesota DWI Court Opinions
Minnesota DWI Enhancement
Minnesota DWI Forfeiture
Minnesota DWI News
Minnesota DWI Statistics
Minnesota DWI Take or Refuse Testing
Minnesota DWI Test Refusal
Minnesota DWI Testing Decision
Minnesota DWI Urine Testing
Minnesota Felony DWI
Minnesota Ignition Interlock
Minnesota Immigration and DWI
Minnesota Implied Consent Advisory
Minnesota Implied Consent License Revocation
Minnesota Intoxilyzer Source Code Litigation
Minnesota Police Surveillance
Minnesota Right to Counsel in DWI Case
Minnesota Whiskey Plates
powered by

Minneapolis DWI Attorney Blog

State's Destruction of Blood Sample Prior to DWI Trial Violated Due Process

In State v. Hawkinson, decided March 26, 2012, the Minnesota Court of Appeals ruled that the State of Minnesota violated defendant's due process rights by destroying defendant's blood sample before the DWI trial and after defendant's specific demand to preserve the blood sample for trial. The court of appeals relied on the seminal U.S. Supreme Court case of Brady v. Maryland, which established that the “suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to an accused upon request violates due process where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment, irrespective of the good faith or bad faith of the prosecution.” 
 
In Hawkinson, the trial court ruled that defendant's blood sample indicating an alcohol concentration of 0.11 was inadmissible at trial due to the destruction of the sample, violating due process. The prosecutor appealed the pretrial ruling, and the Court of Appeals rejected the prosecutor's appeal.
 
Scientists at the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension are responsible for testing blood and urine samples in DWI cases. The BCA's general policy is to destroy the samples after one year. Despite defense counsel's specific request to preserve the blood sample for trial, the BCA went ahead and destroyed the sample prior pursuant to its policy. Likely, the BCA was unaware of the defendant's specific request to preserve the sample for trial. Nonetheless, the BCA's actions violated defendant's due process rights, and the State no longer could introduce evidence of defendant's blood alcohol concentration at trial. 
 
Most DWI cases in Minnesota are brought to trial within one year, and thus the BCA's policy usually is not an issue. However, some cases take more than a year to go to trial, depending on the county and the issues being litigated.
 
This case demonstrates that common sense doesn't always prevail at government agencies. One might assume that the BCA would preserve all evidence until trial, but that has never been the BCA's policy in DWI cases.
 
 
 

3 Comments to State's Destruction of Blood Sample Prior to DWI Trial Violated Due Process:

Comments RSS
Ben - researching DWI law and cases on Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:33 PM
I continue to find cases like this in my research. As with all other criminal charges, the police and state have to follow so many different steps within a procedure and sometimes things are bound to get missed. But, I feel like I've read a lot more recently. People getting lazy? Hmmm.... Thanks for posting - great blog btw!
Reply to comment


Ben - researching DWI law and cases on Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:34 PM
Been reading a lot of these types of stories as of late. I know there are a lot of different procedures for the cops and the state to follow with a proper DWI, but are people getting lazy? Hmm....
Reply to comment


riverside dui lawyer on Tuesday, August 07, 2012 12:43 PM
I've seen other stories like this. Absolutely ridiculous that a lab would destroy evidence, especially after a defendant specifically asked to have the evidence preserved. Buy one less charger or patrol car, get some more storage space, and hang onto samples for two years or something. Crazy
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Website:
Comment:
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment